1982 Thompson Gymnasium, Elizabethtown ELIZABETHTOWN BLUE JAYS UNC Greensboro Spartans 67-66 ot
1983 Kneller Athletics Center, Worcester NORTH CENTRAL CARDINALS Elizabethtown Blue Jays 83-71
1984 John Long Center, Scranton RUST BEARCATS Elizabethtown Blue Jays 51-49
1985 Schuldes Sports Center, De Pere SCRANTON ROYALS New Rochelle Blue Angels 68-59
1986 Twohig Gymnasium, Salem SALEM STATE VIKINGS Bishop College 89-85
1987 John Long Center, Scranton WISCONSIN-STEVENS POINT POINTERS Concordia-Moorhead Cobbers 81-74
1988 Memorial Auditorium, Moorhead CONCORDIA-MOORHEAD COBBERS St. John Fisher Cardinals 65-57
1989 Alumni Gymnasium, Danville ELIZABETHTOWN BLUE JAYS Cal State Stanislaus Warriors 66-65
1990 Holland Civic Center, Holland HOPE FLYING DUTCHMEN St. John Fisher Cardinals 65-63
1991 Schoenecker Arena, St. Paul ST. THOMAS TOMMIES Muskingum Fighting Muskies 73-55
1992 Johnston Hall, Bethlehem ALMA SCOTS Moravian Greyhounds 79-75
1993 Kuyper Gymnasium, Pella CENTRAL DUTCH Capital Crusaders 71-63
1994 W.L. Zorn Arena, Eau Claire CAPITAL CRUSADERS Washington University Bears 82-63
1995 Alumni Gymnasium, Columbus CAPITAL CRUSADERS Wisconsin Oshkosh Titans 59-55
1996 Albee Hall, Oshkosh WISCONSIN OSHKOSH TITANS Mount Union Purple Raiders 66-50
1997 Coles Sports Center, New York City NYU VIOLETS Wisconsin Eau Claire Blugolds 72-70
1998 Warren Hill Gymnasium, Gorham WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY BEARS Southern Maine Huskies 77-69
1999 Stephen Feldman Arena, Danbury WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY BEARS St. Benedict Blazers 74-65
2000 Stephen Feldman Arena, Danbury WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY BEARS Southern Maine Huskies 79-33
2001 Stephen Feldman Arena, Danbury WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY BEARS Messiah Falcons 67-45
2002 Hulbert Arena, Terre Haute WISCONSIN-STEVENS POINT POINTERS St. Lawrence Saints 67-65
2003 Hulbert Arena, Terre Haute TRINITY TIGERS Eastern Connecticut State Warriors 60-58
2004 Jane P. Batten Student Center, Virginia Beach WILMINGTON QUAKERS Bowdoin Polar Bears 59-53
2005 Jane P. Batten Student Center, Virginia Beach MILLIKIN BIG BLUE Randolph-Macon Yellow Jackets 70-50
2006 Springfield Civic Center, Springfield HOPE FLYING DUTCHMEN Southern Maine Huskies 69-56
2007 Springfield Civic Center, Springfield DEPAUW TIGERS Washington University Bears 55-52
2008 DeVos Fieldhouse, Holland HOWARD PAYNE YELLOW JACKETS Messiah Falcons 68-54
2009 DeVos Fieldhouse, Holland GEORGE FOX BRUINS Washington University Bears 60-53
2010 Shirk Center, Bloomington WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY BEARS Hope Flying Dutchmen 65-59
2011 Shirk Center, Bloomington AMHERST MAMMOTHS Washington University Bears 64-55
2012 DeVos Fieldhouse, Holland ILLINOIS WESLEYAN TITANS George Fox Bruins 57-48
2013 DeVos Fieldhouse, Holland DEPAUW TIGERS Wisconsin-Whitewater Warhawks 69-51
2014 Warren Hill Gymnasium, Gorham FAIRLEIGH DICKINSON-FLORHAM DEVILS Whitman College 80-72
2015 Van Noord Arena, Grand Rapids THOMAS MORE SAINTS George Fox Bruins 83-63
2016 Bankers Life Fieldhouse, Indianapolis THOMAS MORE SAINTS Tufts University 63-51
2017 Van Noord Arena, Grand Rapids AMHERST MAMMOTHS Tufts University 52-29
2018 Mayo Civic Center, Rochester AMHERST MAMMOTHS Bowdoin Polar Bears 59-53
2019 Cregger Center, Salem THOMAS MORE SAINTS Bowdoin Polar Bears 81-67
2020 Capital University Performance, Columbus cancellato per l'emergenza Coronavirus
2021 Cregger Center, Salem cancellato per l'emergenza Coronavirus
2022 UPMC Cooper Fieldhouse, Pittsburgh HOPE FLYING DUTCHMEN UW-Whitewater Warhawks 71-58
2023 American Airlines Center, Dallas TRANSYLVANIA Christopher Newport Captains 57-52
2024 Capital University Performance Arena, Columbus NYU VIOLETS Smith College 51-41
2025 Cregger Center, Salem - -
2026 Cregger Center, Salem - -