Hall of Fame Bowl
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1986 | James JACKSON | GEORGIA BULLDOGS | Quarterback |
| Garry MOSS | GEORGIA BULLDOGS | Cornerback | |
| 1988 | Jamie MORRIS | MICHIGAN WOLVERINES | Tailback |
| 1989 | Robert DRUMMOND | SYRACUSE ORANGEMEN | Running Back |
| 1990 | Reggie SLACK | AUBURN TIGERS | Quarterback |
| 1991 | DeChane CAMERON | CLEMSON TIGERS | Quarterback |
| 1992 | Marvin GRAVES | SYRACUSE ORANGEMEN | Quarterback |
| 1993 | Heath SHULER | TENNESSEE VOLUNTEERS | Quarterback |
| 1994 | Tyrone WHEATLEY | MICHIGAN WOLVERINES | Running Back |
| 1995 | Terrell FLETCHER | WISCONSIN BADGERS | Running Back |
Outback Bowl
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | Bobby ENGRAM | PENN STATE NITTANY LIONS | Wide Receiver |
| 1997 | Dwayne RUDD | ALABAMA CRIMSON TIDE | Linebacker |
| 1998 | Mike BOBO | GEORGIA BULLDOGS | Quarterback |
| 1999 | Courtney BROWN | PENN STATE NITTANY LIONS | Defensive End |
| 2000 | Drew BRESS | PURDUE BOILERMAKERS | Quarterback |
| 2001 | Ryan BREWER | SOUTH CAROLINA GAMECOCKS | Running Back |
| 2002 | Phil PETTY | SOUTH CAROLINA GAMECOCKS | Quarterback |
| 2003 | Chris PERRY | MICHIGAN WOLVERINES | Tailback |
| 2004 | Fred RUSSELL | IOWA HAWKEYES | Running Back |
| 2005 | David POLLACK | GEORGIA BULLDOGS | Defensive End |
| 2006 | Dallas BAKER | FLORIDA GATORS | Wide Receiver |
| 2007 | Tony HUNT | PENN STATE NITTANY LIONS | Running Back |
| 2008 | Erik AINGE | TENNESSEE VOLUNTEERS | Quarterback |
| 2009 | Shonn GREENE | IOWA HAWKEYES | Running Back |
| 2010 | Darvin ADAMS | AUBURN TIGERS | Wide Receiver |
| 2011 | Ahmad BLACK | FLORIDA GATORS | Safety |
| 2012 | Brandon BOYKIN | GEORGIA BULLDOGS | Cornerback |
| 2013 | Ace SANDERS | SOUTH CAROLINA GAMECOCKS | Wide Receiver |
| 2014 | Jeremy HILL | LSU TIGERS | Running Back |
| 2015 | Melvin GORDON | WISCONSIN BADGERS | Running Back |
| 2016 | Jalen HURD | TENNESSEE VOLUNTEERS | Running Back |
| 2017 | Chauncey GARDNER | FLORIDA GATORS | Defensive Back |
| 2018 | Jake BENTLEY | SOUTH CAROLINA GAMECOCKS | Quarterback |
| 2019 | Nick EASLEY | IOWA HAWKEYES | Wide Receiver |
| 2020 | Tyler JOHNSON | MINNESOTA GOLDEN GOPHERS | Wide Receiver |
| 2021 | Matt CORRAL | OLE MISS REBELS | Quarterback |
| 2022 | K.J. JEFFERSON | ARKANSAS RAZORBACKS | Quarterback |
ReliaQuest Bowl
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Justin ROBINSON | MISSISSIPPI STATE BULLDOGS | Wide Receiver |
| 2024 | Garrett NUSSMEIER | LSU TIGERS | Quarterback |
| 2024 | Jordan MARSHALL | MICHIGAN WOLVERINES | Running Back |