| Dall'esordio, come Humanitarian Bowl, fino al 2014 vennero selezionati due MVP per ogni gara, un giocatore per la squadra vincitrice e uno per la squadra sconfitta. Dal 2015 viene eletto un singolo MVP. |
|---|
Humanitarian Bowl
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1997 | Chad PLUMMER | CINCINNATI BEARCATS | Quarterback |
| Steve SMITH | UTAH STATE AGGIES | Wide Receiver | |
| 1998 | John WELSH | IDAHO VANDALS | Quarterback |
| Lee ROBERTS | SOUTHERN MISS GOLDEN EAGLES | Quarterback | |
| 1999 | Brock FORSEY | BOISE STATE BRONCOS | Running Back |
| Chris REDMAN | LOUISVILLE CARDINALS | Quarterback | |
| 2000 | Bart HENDRICKS | BOISE STATE BRONCOS | Quarterback |
| Chris PORTER | UTEP MINERS | Running Back | |
| 2001 | Woodrow DANTZLER | CLEMSON TIGERS | Quarterback |
| Delwyn DAIGRE | LOUISIANA TECH BULLDOGS | Wide Receiver | |
| 2002 | Bobby HAMMER | BOISE STATE BRONCOS | Defensive Tackle |
| Anthony FORREST | IOWA STATE CYCLONES | Defensive Back | |
| 2004 | P. J. DANIELS | GEORGIA TECH YELLOW JACKETS | Running Back |
| Cort MOFFITT | TULSA GOLDEN HURRICANE | Punter |
MPC Computers Bowl
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2004 | Paul PINEGAR | FRESNO STATE BULLDOGS | Quarterback |
| Marques HAGANS | VIRGINIA CAVALIERS | Quarterback | |
| 2005 | Matt RYAN | BOSTON COLLEGE EAGLES | Quarterback |
| Jared ZABRANSKY | BOISE STATE BRONCOS | Quarterback | |
| 2006 | Kirby FREEMAN | MIAMI HURRICANES | Quarterback |
| Jeff ROWE | NEVADA WOLF PACK | Quarterback |
Humanitarian Bowl
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 | Tom BRANDSTATER | FRESNO STATE BULLDOGS | Quarterback |
| Jonathan DWYER | GEORGIA TECH YELLOW JACKETS | Running Back | |
| 2008 | Da'Rel SCOTT | MARYLAND TERRAPINS | Running Back |
| Colin KAEPERNICK | NEVADA WOLF PACK | Quarterback | |
| 2009 | DeMaundray WOOLRIDGE | IDAHO VANDALS | Running Back |
| Freddie BARNES | BOWLING GREEN FALCONS | Wide Receiver | |
| 2010 | Chandler HARNISH | NORTHERN ILLINOIS HUSKIES | Quarterback |
| Ryan COLBURN | FRESNO STATE BULLDOGS | Quarterback |
Famous Idaho Potato Bowl
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2011 | LaVon BRAZILL | OHIO BOBCATS | Wide Receiver |
| Michael SMITH | UTAH STATE AGGIES | Running Back | |
| 2012 | Kerwynn WILLIAMS | UTAH STATE AGGIES | Running Back |
| Bernard REEDY | TOLEDO ROCKETS | Wide Receiver | |
| 2013 | Adam MUEMA | SAN DIEGO STATE AZTECS | Running Back |
| Branden OLIVER | BUFFALO BULLS | Running Back | |
| 2014 | Shayne DAVERN | AIR FORCE FALCONS | Running Back |
| Corey DAVIS | WESTERN MICHIGAN BRONCOS | Wide Receiver | |
| 2015 | Robert STEIN | AKRON ZIPS | Kicker |
| 2016 | Matt LINEHAN | IDAHO VANDALS | Quarterback |
| 2017 | Josh ALLEN | WYOMING COWBOYS | Quarterback |
| 2018 | Zach WILSON | BYU COUGARS | Quarterback |
| 2020 | Nathan ROURKE | OHIO BOBCATS | Quarterback |
| 2020 | Carson STRONG | NEVADA WOLF PACK | Quarterback |
| 2021 | Levi WILLIAMS | WYOMING COWBOYS | Quarterback |
| 2022 | Taylor POWELL | EASTERN MICHIGAN EAGLES | Quarterback |
| 2023 | Darren GRAINGER | GEORGIA STATE PANTHERS | Quarterback |
| 2024 | Josh HOLST | NORTHERN ILLINOIS HUSKIES | Quarterback |