Nella prima edizione del Boca Raton Bowl venne eletto un solo MVP. A partire dal 2015 vengono selezionati un giocatore per l'attacco e un giocatore per la difesa. Dal 2019 viene selezionato un altro MVP per gli Special Teams.

 

Anno Vincitore Squadra Ruolo
2014 Rakeem CATO MARSHALL THUNDERING HERD Quarterback
2015 Phillip ELY TOLEDO ROCKETS Quarterback
  Ju'Wan WOODLEY TOLEDO ROCKETS Linebacker
2016 Anthony WALES WESTERN KENTUCKY HILLTOPPERS Running Back
  Keith BROWN WESTERN KENTUCKY HILLTOPPERS Linebacker
2017 Jason DRISKEL FLORIDA ATHLETIC OWLS Quarterback
  Azeez AL-SHAAIR FLORIDA ATHLETIC OWLS Linebacker
2018 Xavier UBOSI UAB BLAZERS Wide Receiver
  Anthony RUSH UAB BLAZERS Nose Tackle
2019 Chris ROBINSON FLORIDA ATHLETIC OWLS Quarterback
  Rashad SMITH FLORIDA ATHLETIC OWLS Linebacker
  Matt HAYBALL FLORIDA ATHLETIC OWLS Punter
2020 Zach WILSON BYU COUGARS Quarterback
  Keenan PILI BYU COUGARS Linebacker
  Caleb CHRISTENSEN BYU COUGARS Kick Returner
2021 Bailey ZAPPE WESTERN KENTUCKY HILLTOPPERS Quarterback
  Antwon KINCADE WESTERN KENTUCKY HILLTOPPERS Defensive Back
  John HAGGERTY III WESTERN KENTUCKY HILLTOPPERS Punter
2022 Dequan FINN TOLEDO ROCKETS Quarterback
  Nate GIVHAN TOLEDO ROCKETS Linebacker
  Thomas CLUCKEY TOLEDO ROCKETS Kicker
2023 Byrum BROWN SOUTH FLORIDA BULLS Quarterback
  Daquan EVANS SOUTH FLORIDA BULLS Defensive Back
  Aamaris BROWN SOUTH FLORIDA BULLS Defensive Back
2024 JC EVANS JAMES MADISON DUKES Quarterback
  DJ BARKSDALE JAMES MADISON DUKES Nickelback
  Ryan HANSON JAMES MADISON DUKES Punter