David C. Koch MVP Trophy
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2010 | Delone CARTER | SYRACUSE ORANGE | Running Back |
| 2011 | Jawan JAMISON | RUTGERS SCARLET KNIGHTS | Running Back |
| 2012 | Prince-Tyson GULLEY | SYRACUSE ORANGE | Running Back |
| 2013 | Zach MARTIN | NOTRE DAME FIGHTING IRISH | Offensive Tackle |
| 2014 | Christian HACKENBERG | PENN STATE NITTANY LIONS | Quarterback |
| 2015 | Thomas SIRK | DUKE BLUE DEVILS | Quarterback |
| Shaun WILSON | DUKE BLUE DEVILS | Running Back | |
| 2016 | Justin JACKSON | NORTHWESTERN WILDCATS | Running Back |
| 2017 | Akrum WADLEY | IOWA HAWKEYES | Running Back |
| 2018 | Jonathan TAYLOR | WISCONSIN BADGERS | Running Back |
| 2019 | Brian LEWERKE | MICHIGAN STATE SPARTANS | Quarterback |
| 2020 | New Era Pinstripe Bowl cancellato per l'emergenza Covid-19 |
||
| 2021 | Taulia TAGOVAILOA | MARYLAND TERRAPINS | Quarterback |
| 2022 | Coleman BRYSON | MINNESOTA GOLDEN GOPHERS | Safety |
| 2023 | Kyle MONANGAI | RUTGERS SCARLET KNIGHTS | Running Back |
| 2024 | Rahmir JOHNSON | NEBRASKA CORNHUSKERS | Running Back |