| La prima assegnazione del premio di Most Valuable Player al Pro Bowl avvenne nel 1951. Dal 1957 al 1971 vennero eletti il miglio attaccante di seconda linea e il miglio difensore di linea. Nel 1972 il miglior attaccante e il miglior difensore. Dal 1973 al 2013 il premio venne assegnato ad un vincitore assoluto. Dal 2014 si è ritornati a premiare un giocatore del reparto offensivo e uno del reparto difensivo. |
|---|
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1951 | Otto GRAHAM | CLEVELAND BROWNS | Quarterback |
| 1952 | Dan TOWLER | LOS ANGELES RAMS | Running Back |
| 1953 | Don DOLL | DETROIT LIONS | Defensive Back |
| 1954 | Chuck BEDNARIK | PHILADELPHIA EAGLES | Linebacker |
| 1955 | Billy WILSON | SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS | End |
| 1956 | Ollie MATSON | CHICAGO CARDINALS | Running Back |
| 1957 | Bert RECHICHAR | BALTIMORE COLTS | Back |
| 1 | Ernie STAUTNER | PITTSBURGH STEELERS | Lineman |
| 1958 | Hugh McELHENNY | SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS | Back |
| Gene BRITO | WASHINGTON REDSKINS | Lineman | |
| 1959 | Frank GIFFORD | NEW YORK GIANTS | Back |
| Doug ATKINS | CHICAGO BEARS | Lineman | |
| 1960 | Johnny UNITAS | BALTIMORE COLTS | Back |
| Big Daddy LIPSCOMB | PITTSBURGH STEELERS | Lineman | |
| 1961 | Johnny UNITAS | BALTIMORE COLTS | Back |
| Sam HUFF | NEW YORK GIANTS | Lineman | |
| 1962 | Jim BROWN | CLEVELAND BROWNS | Back |
| Henry JORDAN | GREEN BAY PACKERS | Lineman | |
| 1963 | Jim BROWN | CLEVELAND BROWN | Back |
| Big Daddy LIPSCOMB | PITTSBURGH STEELERS | Lineman | |
| 1964 | Johnny UNITAS | BALTIMORE COLTS | Back |
| Gino MARCHETTI | BALTIMORE COLTS | Lineman | |
| 1965 | Fran TARKENTON | MINNESOTA VIKINGS | Back |
| Terry BARR | DETROIT LIONS | Lineman | |
| 1966 | Jim BROWN | CLEVELAND BROWNS | Back |
| Dale MEINERT | ST. LOUIS CARDINALS | Lineman | |
| 1967 | Gale SAYERS | CHICAGO BEARS | Back |
| Floyd PETERS | PHILADELPHIA EAGLES | Lineman | |
| 1968 | Gale SAYERS | CHICAGO BEARS | Back |
| Dave ROBINSON | GREEN BAY PACKERS | Lineman | |
| 1969 | Roman GABRIEL | LOS ANGELES RAMS | Back |
| Merlin OLSEN | LOS ANGELES RAMS | Lineman | |
| 1970 | Gale SAYERS | CHICAGO BEARS | Back |
| George ANDRIE | DALLAS COWBOYS | Lineman | |
| 1971 | Mel RENFRO | DALLAS COWBOYS | Back |
| Fred CARR | GREEN BAY PACKERS | Lineman | |
| 1972 | Jan STENERUD | KANSAS CITY CHIEFS | Offense |
| Willie LANIER | KANSAS CITY CHIEFS | Defense | |
| 1973 | O.J. SIMPSON | BUFFALO BILLS | Running Back |
| 1974 | Garo YEPREMIAN | MIAMI DOLPHINS | Placekicker |
| 1975 | James HARRIS | LOS ANGELES RAMS | Quarterback |
| 1976 | Billy "White Shoes" JOHNSON | HOUSTON OILERS | Kick Returner |
| 1977 | Mel BLOUNT | PITTSBURGH STEELERS | Cornerback |
| 1978 | Walter PAYTON | CHICAGO BEARS | Running Back |
| 1979 | Ahmad RASHĀD | MINNESOTA VIKINGS | Wide Receiver |
| 1980 | Chuck MUNCIE | NEW ORLEANS SAINTS | Running Back |
| 1981 | Eddie MURRAY | DETROIT LIONS | Placekicker |
| 1982 | Kellen WINSLOW | SAN DIEGO CHARGERS | Tight End |
| Lee Roy SELMON | TAMPA BAY BUCCANEERS | Defensive End | |
| 1983 | Dan FOUTS | SAN DIEGO CHARGERS | Quarterback |
| John JEFFERSON | GREEN BAY PACKERS | Wide Receiver | |
| 1984 | Joe THEISMANN | WASHINGTON REDSKINS | Quarterback |
| 1985 | Mark GASTINEAU | NEW YORK JETS | Defensive End |
| 1986 | Phil SIMMS | NEW YORK GIANTS | Quarterback |
| 1987 | Reggie WHITE | PHILADELPHIA EAGLES | Defensive End |
| 1988 | Bruce SMITH | BUFFALO BILLS | Defensive End |
| 1989 | Randall CUNNINGHAM | PHILADELPHIA EAGLES | Quarterback |
| 1990 | Jerry GRAY | LOS ANGELES RAMS | Cornerback |
| 1991 | Jim KELLY | BUFFALO BILLS | Quarterback |
| 1992 | Michael IRVIN | DALLAS COWBOYS | Wide Receiver |
| 1993 | Steve TASKER | BUFFALO BILLS | Special Team |
| 1994 | Andre RISON | ATLANTA FALCONS | Wide Receiver |
| 1995 | Marshall FAULK | INDIANAPOLIS COLTS | Running Back |
| 1996 | Jerry RICE | SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS | Wide Receiver |
| 1997 | Mark BRUNELL | JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS | Quarterback |
| 1998 | Warren MOON | SEATTLE SEAHAWKS | Quarterback |
| 1999 | Ty LAW | NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS | Cornerback |
| Keyshawn JOHNSON | NEW YORK JETS | Wide Receiver | |
| 2000 | Randy MOSS | MINNESOTA VIKINGS | Wide Receiver |
| 2001 | Rich GANNON | OAKLAND RAIDERS | Quarterback |
| 2002 | Rich GANNON | OAKLAND RAIDERS | Quarterback |
| 2003 | Ricky WILLIAMS | MIAMI DOLPHINS | Running Back |
| 2004 | Marc BULGER | SAINT LOUIS RAMS | Quarterback |
| 2005 | Peyton MANNING | INDIANAPOLIS COLTS | Quarterback |
| 2006 | Derrick BROOKS | TAMPA BAY BUCCANEERS | Linebacker |
| 2007 | Carson PALMER | CINCINNATI BENGALS | Quarterback |
| 2008 | Adrian PETERSON | MINNESOTA VIKINGS | Running Back |
| 2009 | Larry FITZGERALD | ARIZONA CARDINALS | Wide Receiver |
| 2010 | Matt SCHAUB | HOUSTON TEXANS | Quarterback |
| 2011 | DeAngelo HALL | WASHINGTON REDSKINS | Cornerback |
| 2012 | Brandon MARSHALL | MIAMI DOLPHINS | Wide Receiver |
| 2013 | Kyle RUDOLPH | MINNESOTA VIKINGS | Tight End |
| 2014 | Nick FOLES | PHILADELPHIA EAGLES | Quarterback |
| Derrick JOHNSON | KANSAS CITY CHIEFS | Linebacker | |
| 2015 | Matthew STAFFORD | DETROIT LIONS | Quarterback |
| J.J. WATT | HOUSTON TEXANS | Defensive End | |
| 2016 | Russell WILSON | SEATTLE SEAHAWKS | Quarterback |
| Michael BENNETT | SEATTLE SEAHAWKS | defensive End | |
| 2017 | Travis KELCE | KANSAS CITY CHIEFS | Tight End |
| Lorenzo ALEXANDER | BUFFALO BILLS | Linebacker | |
| 2018 | Delanie WALKER | TENNESSEE TITANS | Tight End |
| Von MILLER | DENVER BRONCOS | Linebacker | |
| 2019 | Patrick MAHONES | KANSAS CITY CHIEFS | Quarterback |
| Jamal ADAMS | NEW YORK JETS | Safety | |
| 2020 | Lamar JACKSON | BALTIMORE RAVENS | Quarterback |
| Calais CAMPBELL | JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS | defensive End | |
| 2021 | Pro Bowl cancellato per l'emergenza Coronavirus |
||
| 2022 | Justin HERBERT | LOS ANGELES CHARGERS | Quarterback |
| Maxx CROSBY | LAS VEGAS RAIDERS | Defensive End | |
| 2023 | - | - | - |
| - | - | - | |
| 2024 | Baker MAYFIELD | TAMPA BAY BUCCANEERS | Quarterback |
| Demario DAVIS | NEW ORLEANS SAINTS | Linebacker | |
| 2025 | Jared GOFF | DETROIT LIONS | Quarterback |
| Byron MURPHY | MINNESOTA VIKINGS | Cornerback | |